God ad intra and God ad extra
The Relationship between the Immanent Trinity and the Economic Trinity as Reflected in the Works of John Zizioulas and Dumitru Stăniloae
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.63394/6cafyv14Keywords:
John Zizioulas, Dumitru Stăniloae, theologia and oikonomia, monarchy of the Father, relations of origin, Filioque, apophatic theology, self-revelation, salvation history, deification, Orthodox–Catholic dialogueAbstract
This article compares the relationship between the immanent and economic Trinity in John Zizioulas and Dumitru Stăniloae. Although they did not explicitly engage one another’s work, their approaches share a patristic inheritance while revealing distinctive emphases. After outlining the Orthodox distinction between God ad intra and God ad extra, the article examines divine transcendence, freedom, and communion. Zizioulas stresses the irreducibility of God’s eternal life to salvation history, safeguarding divine freedom against historical necessity. Stăniloae maintains this distinction while exploring how eternal Trinitarian communion is manifested in history, particularly through the relationship between the Son and the Spirit. Their difference concerns theological priorities rather than an opposition between separation and identity. Both affirm that the God revealed in history is the eternal Triune God, whose mystery revelation discloses without exhausting.
Downloads
References
Asproulis, Nikolaos. "John Zizioulas." In Orthodox Handbook for Ecumenism: Resources for Theological Education, edited by Pantelis Kalaitzidis, Cyril Hovorun, et al., 254–57. Volos: Volos Academy Publications in cooperation with WCC Publications and Regnum Books International, 2014.
Ayres, Lewis. Augustine and the Trinity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
Barth, Karl. Church Dogmatics: The Doctrine of the Word of God. Vol. 1, part 1. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1975.
Barth, Karl. The Göttingen Dogmatics: Instruction in the Christian Religion. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1991.
Berger, Calinic. "Does the Eucharist Make the Church? An Ecclesiological Comparison of Stăniloae and Zizioulas." St. Vladimir’s Theological Quarterly 51, no. 1 (2007): 23–70.
Berger, Calinic. "Dumitru Stăniloae." In Key Theological Thinkers: From Modern to Postmodern, edited by Staale Johannes Kristiansen and Svein Rise, 393–402. Farnham: Ashgate, 2013.
Bordeianu, Radu. Dumitru Stăniloae: An Ecumenical Ecclesiology. London: Bloomsbury, 2011.
Bulgakov, Sergius. The Comforter. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2004.
Chiapetti, Dario. The Father’s Eternal Freedom: The Personalist Trinitarian Ontology of John Zizioulas. Cambridge: James Clarke & Co., 2022.
Clément, Olivier. "Grégoire de Cypre: 'De l’exporèse du Saint Esprit.'" Istina 17, nos. 3–4 (1972): 443–56.
Clément, Olivier. "Vladimir Lossky, un théologien de la personne et du Saint Esprit." Messager de l’Exarchat du Patriarche Russe en Europe Occidentale 8 (1959): 137–206.
Collins, Paul M. Trinitarian Theology, West and East: Karl Barth, the Cappadocian Fathers, and John Zizioulas. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001.
Coman, Augustin (Viorel). "Hristologia Sinodului I Ecumenic de la Niceea (325): Theologia & Oikonomia" [The Christology of the First Ecumenical Council of Nicaea (325): Theologia & Oikonomia]. In Sinodul I Ecumenic de la Niceea (325): Credința ortodoxă – baza unității Bisericii [The First Ecumenical Council of Nicaea (325): Christian Faith—the Basis of the Church’s Unity], edited by Sorin Șelaru, Nicușor Beldiman, George Grigoriță, and Augustin (Viorel) Coman, 263–81. Bucharest: Basilica, 2025.
Coman, Viorel. "Different Orthodox Perspectives on the Ecclesiological Ramifications of the Filioque: Trinitarian Ecclesiology vs. Eucharistic Ecclesiology." Logos: A Journal of Eastern Christian Studies 58, nos. 1–4 (2017): 1–22.
Coman, Viorel. Dumitru Stăniloae’s Trinitarian Ecclesiology: Orthodoxy and the Filioque. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books/Fortress Academic, 2019.
Coman, Viorel. "Dumitru Stăniloae on the Filioque: The Trinitarian Relationship Between the Son and the Spirit, and Its Relevance for the Ecclesiological Synthesis between Christology and Pneumatology." Journal of Ecumenical Studies 49, no. 4 (2014): 553–76.
Coman, Viorel. "Le Saint-Esprit comme liaison de l’amour éternel entre le Père et le Fils: un cas de 'sobornicité ouverte' dans la théologie orthodoxe moderne." Irénikon 89, no. 1 (2016): 25–51.
Coman, Viorel. "Orthodox Neo-Patristic Theology and the West: Dumitru Stăniloae on the Holy Spirit in the Church." Journal of Eastern Christian Studies 74, nos. 3–4 (2022): 262–78.
Congar, Yves. I Believe in the Holy Spirit. Vol. 3. Translated by David Smith. New York: Seabury Press, 1983.
Congar, Yves. Je crois en l’Esprit Saint: Le fleuve de vie qui coule en Orient et en Occident. Vol. 3. Paris: Éditions du Cerf, 1980.
Durand, Emmanuel. "L’identité rahnérienne entre la Trinité économique et la Trinité immanente à l’épreuve de ses applications." Revue Thomiste 103, no. 1 (2003): 75–92.
Farrow, Douglas. "Person and Nature: The Necessity-Freedom Dialectic in John Zizioulas." In The Theology of John Zizioulas: Personhood and the Church, edited by Douglas H. Knight, 109–23. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2007.
Fox, Patricia. God as Communion: John Zizioulas, Elizabeth Johnson, and the Retrieval of the Symbol of the Triune God. Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 2001.
Ică Jr., Ioan. "Stăniloae, Dumitru (1903–1993)." In The Dictionary of Historical Theology, edited by Trevor A. Hart, 527–31. Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans, 2000.
Kabuya, Godefroid Mukenge. Le « Grundaxiom » de Karl Rahner comme paradigme du renouveau trinitaire au XXe siècle: Une relecture interdisciplinaire. Bern: Peter Lang, 2019.
Knight, Douglas H., ed. The Theology of John Zizioulas: Personhood and the Church. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2007.
Le Guillou, Marie-Joseph. "La critique du filioque de L. P. Karsavine." Istina 17, nos. 3–4 (1972): 304–7.
Louth, Andrew. Modern Orthodox Thinkers: From the Philokalia to the Present. London: SPCK, 2015.
Lysack, Maxym. Asceticism and the Eucharist: Exploring Orthodox Spirituality with Metropolitan John Zizioulas. London: Darton, Longman and Todd, 2023.
Maican, Petre. "Dumitru Stăniloae (1903–93)." In T&T Clark Handbook of Modern Theology, edited by Philip E. Ziegler and R. David Nelson, 673–76. London: T&T Clark, 2026.
Meyendorff, John. A Study of Gregory Palamas. London: SPCK, 1964.
Moga, Ioan. "'Treimea imanentă' și 'Treimea economică': Probleme și perspective ale unei distincții teologice" ["Immanent Trinity" and "Economic Trinity": Problems and Perspectives of a Theological Distinction]. Studii Teologice, new series, 7, no. 3 (2011): 21–56.
Moltmann, Jürgen. The Trinity and the Kingdom of God. Translated by Margaret Kohl. New York: Harper & Row, 1981.
Papanikolaou, Aristotle. Being with God: Trinity, Apophaticism, and Divine-Human Communion. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 2006.
Papanikolaou, Aristotle. "Contemporary Orthodox Currents on the Trinity." In The Oxford Handbook of the Trinity, edited by Gilles Emery, O.P., and Matthew Levering, 328–38. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011.
Papanikolaou, Aristotle. "Is Zizioulas an Existentialist in Disguise? Response to Lucian Turcescu." Modern Theology 20, no. 4 (2004): 601–7.
Papadakis, Aristeides. Crisis in Byzantium: The Filioque Controversy in the Patriarchate of Gregory II of Cyprus (1283–1289). Crestwood, NY: St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1983.
Pino, Tikhon. Essence and Energies: Being and Naming God in St Gregory Palamas. London: Routledge, 2024.
Popescu, Dumitru. Iisus Hristos Pantocrator [Jesus Christ Pantokrator]. Bucharest: Editura Institutului Biblic și de Misiune al Bisericii Ortodoxe Române, 2005.
Rahner, Karl. The Trinity. Translated by Joseph Donceel. New York: Herder and Herder, 1970.
Reid, Duncan. Energies of the Spirit: Trinitarian Models in Eastern Orthodox and Western Theology. Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1997.
Rikheim, Lars Erik. "Johannes Zizioulas." In Key Theological Thinkers: From Modern to Postmodern, edited by Staale Johannes Kristiansen and Svein Rise, 435–47. Farnham: Routledge, 2013.
Rogobete, Silviu-Eugen. "Mystical Existentialism or Communitarian Participation?: Vladimir Lossky and Dumitru Stăniloae." In Dumitru Stăniloae: Tradition and Modernity in Theology, edited by Lucian Turcescu, 167–206. Iași: Center for Romanian Studies, 2003.
Russell, Norman. Gregory Palamas and the Making of Palamism in the Modern Age. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019.
Sanders, Fred. "Entangled in the Trinity: Economic and Immanent Trinity in Recent Theology." Dialog 40, no. 3 (2001): 175–82.
Șelaru, Sorin. "Eternal Intra-Trinitarian Relations and Their Economic Consequences: An Approach according to Father Dumitru Stăniloae’s Theological Perspective." International Journal of Orthodox Theology 2, no. 1 (2011): 83–93.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. Ascetica și mistica Bisericii Ortodoxe. 4th ed. Bucharest: Basilica, 2019. English translation: Orthodox Spirituality: A Practical Guide for the Faithful and a Definitive Manual for the Scholar. South Canaan, PA: St. Tikhon’s Seminary Press, 2002.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. Chipul nemuritor al lui Dumnezeu. 3rd ed. Bucharest: Basilica, 2013.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. Iisus Hristos și restaurarea omului. 3rd ed. Bucharest: Basilica, 2013.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. Sfânta Treime sau la început a fost iubirea. 2nd ed. Bucharest: Editura Institutului Biblic și de Misiune al Bisericii Ortodoxe Române, 2005.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. Spiritualitate și comuniune în Liturghia ortodoxă. 2nd ed. Bucharest: Editura Institutului Biblic și de Misiune al Bisericii Ortodoxe Române, 2004. English translation: Spirituality and Communion in the Orthodox Liturgy. Brookline, MA: Holy Cross Orthodox Press, 2025.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. Teologia dogmatică ortodoxă. 3 vols. 3rd ed. Bucharest: Editura Institutului Biblic și de Misiune al Bisericii Ortodoxe Române, 2003.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. The Experience of God: Orthodox Dogmatic Theology. Vol. 1, Revelation and Knowledge of the Triune God. Translated by Ioan Ionita and Robert Barringer. Brookline, MA: Holy Cross Orthodox Press, 1998.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. The Experience of God: Orthodox Dogmatic Theology. Vol. 3, The Person of Jesus Christ as God and Savior. Translated by Ioan Ioniță. Brookline, MA: Holy Cross Orthodox Press, 2011.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. "Purcederea Duhului Sfânt de la Tatăl și relația lui cu Fiul, ca temei al îndumnezeirii și înfierii noastre." Ortodoxia 31, nos. 3–4 (1979): 583–92. English translation: "The Procession of the Holy Spirit from the Father and His Relation to the Son, as the Basis of Our Deification and Adoption." In Spirit of God, Spirit of Christ: Ecumenical Reflections on the Filioque Controversy, edited by Lukas Vischer, 174–86. Faith and Order Paper no. 103. Geneva: World Council of Churches, 1981.
Stăniloae, Dumitru. "Relațiile Treimice și viața Bisericii." Ortodoxia 16, no. 4 (1964): 503–25. English translation: "Trinitarian Relations and the Life of the Church." In Theology and the Church, 11–44. Crestwood, NY: St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1980.
Turcescu, Lucian, ed. Dumitru Stăniloae: Tradition and Modernity in Theology. Iași: Center for Romanian Studies, 2003.
Turcescu, Lucian. "'Person' versus 'Individual,' and Other Modern Misreadings of Gregory of Nyssa." Modern Theology 18, no. 4 (2002): 527–39.
van Rossum, Joost. "Gregory of Cyprus and Palamism." Studia Patristica 37 (2001): 626–30.
Zizioulas, John D. Being as Communion: Studies in Personhood and the Church. Crestwood, NY: St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1985.
Zizioulas, John D. Communion and Otherness: Further Studies in Personhood and the Church. Edited by Paul McPartlan. London: T&T Clark, 2006.
Zizioulas, John D. Lectures in Christian Dogmatics. Edited by Douglas H. Knight and Katerina Nikolopulu. London: T&T Clark, 2009.
Zizioulas, John D. "Pneumatology and the Importance of the Person." In Communion and Otherness: Further Studies in Personhood and the Church, 178–205. London: T&T Clark, 2006.
Zizioulas, John D. Remembering the Future: Toward an Eschatological Ontology. Edited by Bishop Maxim Vasiljević. Alhambra, CA: Sebastian Press, 2023.
Zizioulas, John D. "The Doctrine of God the Trinity Today: Suggestions for an Ecumenical Study." In The One and the Many: Studies on God, Man, the Church, and the World Today, 3–16. Alhambra, CA: Sebastian Press, 2010.
Zizioulas, John D. The Eucharistic Communion and the World. Edited by Luke Ben Tallon. London: T&T Clark, 2011.
Zizioulas, John D. The One and the Many: Studies on God, Man, the Church, and the World Today. Edited by Gregory Edwards. Alhambra, CA: Sebastian Press, 2010.
Zizioulas, John D. "The Teaching of the Second Ecumenical Council on the Holy Spirit in Historical and Ecumenical Perspective." In Credo in Spiritum Sanctum: Atti del Congresso Teologico Internazionale di Pneumatologia, vol. 1, edited by J. Martins, 29–54. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1983.
Downloads
Received
Revised
Accepted
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 The Author(s)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
